SF District Attorney

Victim Services

Sentence Planning

Prosecutor's Role in Recidivism Reduction

Our prosecutors increasingly recognize that they can – and should – play a key role in recidivism reduction, but they need practical tools to take the leap from ideal to real.

In 2012, the SFDA launched our Sentencing Planning (SP) program, becoming the first office in the State of California to hire a Sentencing Planner. Since then, the program has doubled its capacity with two Sentencing Planners. The program fundamentally transforms the way that prosecutors approach cases by developing individualized sentences that address the needs and risks of justice-involved individuals. It redefines success from the traditional metrics of conviction rates and prison terms to recidivism reduction and community safety.

Disrupting the Cycle of Crime

In 2011, following the passage of AB 109 (California Public Safety Realignment), individuals convicted of non-serious, non-violent, and non-sex crimes were either transferred from state prison to local jails or released on non-custodial mandatory supervision. Many of these individuals returned to the community with minimal or no services to address their criminogenic needs, increasing their risk of recidivating.

In an effort to break this cycle of crime, the SP model focuses on offenders and their readiness for rehabilitation through the application of evidence-based practices designed to reduce reoffending and increase individual accountability.

Evidence Based Practices

The SP model is comprised of two Sentencing Planners with expertise in evidence-based programs to address criminogenic needs, and detailed knowledge of programs and services available in San Francisco.

A team of three Sentencing Planners are assigned cases with young adults, misdemeanor/felony cases and those with mental health needs. The SPs also receive referrals from prosecutors during the early stages of prosecution. An SP conducts an in-depth case review, often including interviews with the defendant and his/her attorney, to determine if alternatives to incarceration are appropriate for the defendant. The SP subsequently provides a written report with detailed recommended dispositions including education requirements, vocational training requirements, rehabilitation and behavior adjustment programs, and, when requested, the length and type of supervision. The prosecutor decides whether to incorporate the SP’s recommendations into his/her final disposition.

Cost and Recidivism Reduction

The SP program redefines a “win” for prosecutors. It reduces costs across all stages of the criminal justice system – from the courthouse, where cases resolve faster, to jails and prisons, to the street, where police no longer expend resources on individuals who would otherwise remain enmeshed in the cycle of crime.

A UC Berkeley evaluation found that recidivism was reduced by 8 percentage points in cases relying on the SP recommendation.

Independent evaluation of the SP program, conducted by UC Berkeley in May 2014, found compelling evidence that it reduces recidivism and prosecutor reliance on incarceration. Currently, we are seeking resources to extend the SP model to our Juvenile Unit.