SF District Attorney

Policy

Sentencing Commission

The Sentencing Commission advises the Mayor and the Board of Supervisors on strategies to improve public safety, reduce recidivism, and reform criminal sentencing

The City and County of San Francisco has improved public safety and reduced our overreliance on incarceration, but there is still a lot of work to be done. The San Francisco Sentencing Commission, which was formed in 2012 and is led by the District Attorney’s Office, advises the Mayor and the Board of Supervisors on strategies to improve public safety, reduce recidivism, modernize the justice system, and reform criminal sentencing. 

Meeting information and archives  

Our approach

Evidence-based decision making

The Sentencing Commission makes recommendations based on best practices, research, and data analysis. It is also responsible for developing inter-agency data collection and reporting standards, tracking sentencing patterns, and analyzing outcomes. This work ensures that decision makers can deliver evidence-based criminal justice reforms. 

View Reports  

Collaboration across agencies

The Sentencing Commission consists of members from the San Francisco District Attorney’s Office, Public Defender’s Office, Adult Probation Department, Juvenile Probation Department, Sheriff’s Department, Police Department, Department of Public Health, Reentry Council, Superior Court, and nonprofits that serve victims and/or formerly incarcerated people. Academic researchers and sentencing experts also serve on the commission. Each member brings a unique perspective that helps generate innovative criminal justice reform strategies.

Agencies & BodiesMembers
District Attorney’s OfficeBrooke Jenkins District Attorney
Public DefenderManohar Raju, Public Defender
Adult ProbationCristel Tullock, Adult Probation Chief
Juvenile ProbationKaty Miller, Juvenile Probation Chief
SheriffPaul Miyamoto, Sheriff
PolicePaul Yep, Interim Police Chief
Department of Public HealthDaniel Tsai
Reentry CouncilKaren Roye, Director Child Support Services
Superior Court*Honorable Rochelle C. East, Presiding Judge
Member of a nonprofit org serving victims chosen by the Family Violence CouncilBeverly Upton, Interim Member
Member of non-profit org working with formerly incarcerated people chosen by the Reentry CouncilWilliam Palmer
Sentencing expert chosen by the Board of SupervisorsTheshia Naidoo, Legal Director, Criminal Justice Drug Policy Alliance
Academic researcher with expertise in data analysis appointed by the MayorMia Bird

* Invited

Commitment to equity and racial justice

In 2018, the Sentencing Commission unanimously approved the Criminal Justice Racial Equity Statement.

View the Criminal Justice Racial Equity Statement → 

Our work

The Sentencing Commission meets regularly to discuss a wide range of topics related to criminal sentencing in San Francisco. Recently, the Commission held hearings on local sentencing trends, procedural justice, the elimination of racial disparities in the justice system – just to name a few. These hearings result in concrete policy recommendations which are submitted to the Mayor and Board of Supervisors annually.

The powers and duties of the Sentencing Commission include: 

  • Recommend evidence-based criminal sentencing strategies; 
  • Consider how to apply best practices from other cities; 
  • Explore community-based alternatives to incarceration;  
  • Recommend changes to the Penal Code and state law to improve the criminal justice system; 
  • Develop a shared definition of recidivism;  
  • Develop data collection and reporting standards; 
  • Facilitate trainings for criminal justice agencies; and 
  • Share information and collaborate with the Reentry Council. 

Resources